An aggressively average offering — but not from a lack of effort. Mahmud Asrar’s art is beautiful as always, so whenever he’s working on the book it is an absolute treat, but although Mark Waid tends to be a solid writer, he just fails to shine on this book.
The story and characters are the major issues. The teens feel misplaced on such an adult team. It gives the feeling that they couldn’t choose between a teen hero book or an adult hero book, and the mixture is simply a let down. Any romance feels like an extreme gimmick rather than anything moving and meaningful — despite how desperately Waid wants it to be moving.
Elements of Vision’s and Thor’s stories could have worked, but they feel too disjointed being put side by side with the teen elements. The book isn’t insulting, or boldly awful in anyway, just bland and poorly blended together.
It’s okay, but lacking.
I dislike Marguerite Bennett most of the time, but she surprises in this book — at least in the first year of this series.
Based on a collection of glorious statues that reimagine the DC heroines as WWII pin-ups, it makes for a striking comic series, based on visuals and designs alone.
One problem is that the book cuts between the point of views and storyline of different characters constantly, at least until the book reaches it’s climax and brings the characters together. A part of me wants to say there are weak links in the story (Catwoman, Zatanna, and Batwoman come to mind), but it’s more that the Wonder Woman parts were so enjoyable that I’m left asking “can we go back to Wonder Woman now?” constantly.
I can only hope Bennett doesn’t devolve into the type of childishness that made her Angela series unreadable. This is definitely her most recommendable series.
Enjoying All-New Captain America, written by Rick Remender with beautiful art by Stuart Immonen, just makes me feel frustrated. And I did enjoy it — a lot actually. More then I thought I would. I would have enjoyed it better if Marvel didn’t constantly cancel and restart every single one of their series in the most frustrating way possible.
There’s a lot to like in All-New Captain America. The new status quo that came out of Rick Remender previous
Captain America Volume 7, which left Steve Rogers old, decrepit with a new feisty son and heir apparent, but leaving his title and name to long time friend and partner Sam Wilson.
But Remender’s All-New Captain America leaves you with merely 6 issues of it. And an unrelated special by another author.
Everything within it feels like potential cut short, and for a book which was such a welcome surprise is a shame. A shame to fall victim to Marvel’s constant relaunching of books. Although the frustration it causes, if you want a book with great art and neat dynamic, I would definitely recommend it. And then recommend Nick Spencer current ongoing Captain America Sam Wilson — before that also gets cut off after 6 issues and an annual.